Lessons in division and unity: the Weimar Republic as a historical case of pernicious polarization and the collapse of democratic trust

Benedek, István (2026) Lessons in division and unity: the Weimar Republic as a historical case of pernicious polarization and the collapse of democratic trust. Journal of Contemporary Central and Eastern Europe, 34 (3). pp. 609-636.

[img]
Preview
Text
Lessons in division and unity the Weimar Republic as a historical case of pernicious polarization and the collapse of democratic trust.pdf - Published Version
Available under license Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial Share Alike.

Download (720kB) | Preview
DOI: 10.1080/25739638.2026.2719475

Abstract

This article revisits the collapse of the Weimar Republic through contemporary polarization theory. It does not offer a new archival explanation but uses a well-studied historical case to clarify how ideological and affective divisions can escalate into pernicious polarization and the collapse of democratic trust. The argument is that Weimar was not doomed by polarization alone. Social-moral cleavages, segmented publics, economic anxieties, political violence and status fears became democratically destructive when political actors transformed them into antagonistic camps that increasingly ceased to recognize opponents as legitimate participants in a shared political order. The article makes three contributions. First, it clarifies the relationship between ideological, affective, pernicious and democratic polarization. Second, it interprets the Nazi promise of Volksgemeinschaft as a strategy of exclusionary unity: National Socialism did not overcome polarization but reorganized it by redefining the political community against internal enemies. Third, it differentiates the mechanisms through which Nazi anti-pluralist mobilization, Communist sectarianism and conservative institutional bypass eroded mutual toleration, institutional restraint, coalition-building and the legitimacy of opposition. The Weimar case illuminates how democratic breakdown becomes more likely when political conflict loses the capacities that make it democratic.

Item Type: Article
Title in English: Lessons in division and unity: the Weimar Republic as a historical case of pernicious polarization and the collapse of democratic trust
Keywords in English: political polarization, socialmoral milieus, cleavages, elite strategies, institutional bypass, democratic breakdown
Subjects: J Political Science > JA Political science (General)
Divisions: Institute for Political Science
Research funder: European Union (EU), MORES project, grant no. 101132601
Depositing User: Enikő Meiszterics
Date Deposited: 17 Nov 2026 20:54
Last Modified: 17 Nov 2026 20:54
Related papers or data collections: Boda, Zsolt (2025) Moral Emotions in Politics - How they unite, how they divide? [Data Collection]
Horst, Dorothea and Scherer, Thomas J. J. (2024) Visionen in der Krise: Deutsche Spitzenkandida innen zur Europawahl 2024 Visions in Crisis: German Lead Candidates for the European Elections 2024. Mediaesthetics – Journal of Poetics of Audiovisual Images, (5). ISSN 2567-9309
Boda, Zsolt and Ring, Orsolya and Szabó, Gabriella (2024) What kinds of emotions are mobilised by different policy fields? A text mining analysis of parliamentary speeches. Working Paper. MORES Working Paper Series, 1. (Unpublished)
Metz, Rudolf and Plesz, Bendegúz (2025) The Irresistible Allure of Charismatic Leaders? Populism, Social Identity, and Polarisation. Politics and Governance, 2025 (13). ISSN 2183-2463
Hadarics, Márton and Krekó, Péter (2024) Nothing to see here, move along! Illiberal contexts as catalyzers of authoritarian misperception of democratic quality. Political Psychology.
Kamkhaji, Jonathan and Radaelli, Claudio M (2025) Behaviour in Public Administration: In Search of Foundational Insights. In: The Humanities and Public Administration; An Introduction. Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd, pp. 79-93.
Metz, Rudolf (2025) (Don't) fear the bad leader: three influential myths about bad leadership. Frontiers in Political Science, 2025 (7). ISSN 2673-3145
Scherer, Thomas and Beichelt, Timm and Illger, Daniel (2025) Inventing an alternative: Populist imaginations of political leaders in audiovisual culture. Working Paper. MORES Working Paper Series, 2. (Unpublished)
Patkós, Veronika and Plesz, Bendegúz (2025) Does political polarisation undermine democratic accountability? Evidence from 28 European democracies. West European Politics. pp. 1-33.
Krekó, Péter (2025) The Rise of the Authoritarian Populist Right: The Illiberal Defenders of Freedom? Brown Journal of World Affairs, XXXI (II).
Sík, Endre and Krekó, Péter (2025) Hungary as an Ideological Informational Autocracy (IA) and the Moral Panic Button (MPB) as its Basic Institution. Central and Eastern European Migration Review. pp. 1-17.
Kamkhaji, Jonathan and Radaelli, Claudio M (2025) Patterns of Emotionalisation in Policy Narratives. Working Paper. MORES Working Paper Series, 3. (Unpublished)
Metz, Rudolf and Kövesdi, Veronika (2026) Teflon leadership: crossing moral boundaries with impunity. Frontiers in Political Science, 2025 (7). ISSN 2673-3145
Hadarics, Márton and Kende, Anna (2025) Social Equality Is Rather Threatening Than Normative to Authoritarians. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 19 (4).
Hadarics, Márton (2025) Democratic Backsliding Based on Illusions: Authoritarians' Biased Perception of Media Freedom Contributes to Their Political Support. International Journal of Psychology, 60 (6).
MORES – Moral Emotions in Politics, (2026) MORES Annual Report: 2025. Project Report. ELTE Centre for Social Sciences.
Benedek, István (2026) Polarizing transition? Opposition strategies and the rise of Péter Magyar and the respect and freedom party (TISZA) in Hungary. Comparative European Politics, 24 (1).
Szabó, Gabriella and Ring, Orsolya and Beichelt, Timm and Lipiński, Artur (2026) Pride and Hubris in European Parliament Campaigns. The cases of Germany, Hungary, and Poland in 2019 and 2024. Working Paper. MORES Working Paper Series, 4. (Unpublished)
Orosz, Gábor and Salamon, János and Enyedi, Zsolt and Whitefield, Stephen and Krekó, Péter (2026) MORES - Moral Emotions in Politics: Cracks in the System: A Democratic Inoculation Intervention that Enhances Recognition of Authoritarian Weaknesses. [Data Collection]
Szabó, Gabriella and Farkas, Eszter and Ring, Orsolya and Beichelt, Timm (2026) Rage to reach: Anger as a political resource for newcomer parties – Facebook communication of German and Hungarian parties and politicians during the 2019 and 2024 European parliamentary campaigns. Communications.
Orosz, Gábor and Salamon, János and Enyedi, Zsolt and Whitefield, Stephen and Krekó, Péter (2026) Cracks in the System. A democratic inoculation intervention that enhances recognition of authoritarian weaknesses. Working Paper. MORES Working Paper Series, 5. (Unpublished)
Szabó, Gabriella and Ring, Orsolya and Lipiński, Artur and Beichelt, Timm (2026) Protecting collective worth: pride in European parliament campaigns in Germany, Hungary, and Poland. Frontiers in Political Science, 2026 (8). ISSN 2673-3145
Triaccca, Nicoló and Kamkhaji, Jonathan C. and Lironi, Elisa (2026) How European Union Policies Feel. Insights from a crowdsourcing study. Working Paper. MORES Working Paper Series, 6. (Unpublished)
Mitró, Dóra (2026) "The 'Fight Club" and the Hidden Truth: Political Video Narratives and the Expression of Moral Emotions in the Shadow of the Pandemic. Politikatudományi Szemle, XXXV (2026/2).
Szabó, Gabriella and Ring, Orsolya and Patkós, Veronika and Boda, Zsolt (2026) Political emotionalization in large text corpora: detecting affective cues with MORESPulse and its scientific uses. JOURNAL OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY & POLITICS.
Szabó, Gabriella and Benedek, István (2026) Cringe Communication in Hungarian Politics Insult Humor as a Campaign Tool in 2024. Central European Journal of Communication, 2(43) (19). pp. 246-270.
Kretchner, Mabelle and Mostovoy, Noga and Halperin, Eran (2026) Conflict, emotions, and policy preferences: How intergroup feelings shape support for peace and punishment across 12 active and post-conflict societies. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished)
Plesz, Bendegúz and Boda, Zsolt (2026) Quickly, efficiently or lawfully? Citizens’ expectations regarding democratic restoration. Project Report. TK, TK KDK.
URI: https://openarchive.tk.mta.hu/id/eprint/687

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item