Paradoxes of populism in the pandemic and beyond: A commentary on Rogers Brubaker’s essay

Boda, Zsolt (2021) Paradoxes of populism in the pandemic and beyond: A commentary on Rogers Brubaker’s essay. Intersections. EEJSP, 7 (3). ISSN 2416-089X

Preview

Text 933-Article Text-3508-1-10-20211229.pdf - Published Version Available under license Creative Commons Attribution No Derivatives. Download (255kB) | Preview

Abstract

In a thoughtful essay, Rogers Brubaker points to the paradoxes of populism unveiled by the pandemic: populists’ difficult relationship with expertise; their challenge of facing a crisis which was not created by them; and their new anti-protectionist feelings that were generated by the alleged overprotectedness of government measures. I certainly agree with him that the pandemic effectively challenged populism, and this is probably the main reason why the COVID-19 crisis, as Brubaker put it, ‘has not generated a coherent or large-scale populist response’ – which could have been expected. After all, populists are supposed to capitalize on crises and, being mostly in opposition, they can easily criticize mainstream politics. Although we cannot say that the pandemic would have swept away populism, it is certainly true that the popularity of populist parties is not soaring. Therefore, I believe Brubaker’s point is valid and the pandemic posed a real challenge to populists.

Item Type:	Article
Title in English:	Paradoxes of populism in the pandemic and beyond: A commentary on Rogers Brubaker’s essay
Keywords in English:	populism, COVID-19 pandemic, political crisis, mainstream political parties, Rogers Brubakers, European populism, populist paradox
Subjects:	H Social Sciences > H Social Sciences (General)
Divisions:	Institute for Political Science
Research funder:	European Union (EU), Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Action DEMOS grant no. 822590
Depositing User:	Enikő Meiszterics
Date Deposited:	03 Feb 2022 10:06
Last Modified:	03 Feb 2022 10:06
Related papers or data collections:	Boda, Zsolt (2019) Democratic Efficacy and the Varieties of Populism in Europe. [Data Collection] Boda, Zsolt and Gorczeski, Vinicius (2020) DEMOS-ANNUAL REPORT, 2019. Project Report. -. DEMOS H2020, (2021) DEMOS-ANNUAL REPORT, 2020/21. Project Report. -. Školkay, Andrej and Žúborová, Viera Populist Political Movement Sme rodina – Boris Kollár (We Are a Family – Boris Kollár). Central European political studies, 2019 (4). pp. 5-26. ISSN 1731-7517 Bene, Márton and Boda, Zsolt (2020) Conceptualizing Democratic Efficacy. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Bennett, Samuel and Lipiński, Artur and Stępińska, Agnieszka and Abadi, David and Baloge, Martin and Bobba, Giuliano and Butkevičienė, Eglė and Brands, Charlotte and Fischer, Agneta and Gammeltoft-Hansen, Thomas and Hubé, Nicolas and Ianosev, Bogdan and Karamanidou, Lena and Klinge, Sune and Kocián, Jiří and Korkut, Umut and Magre, Jaume and Mancosu, Moreno and Marincea, Adina and Matic, Dejan and Medir, Luis and Morkevičius, Vaidas and Pano, Esther and Roncarolo, Franca and Sahin, Osman and Seddone, Antonella and Školkay, Andrej and Szabó, Gabriella and Tsatsanis, Emmanouil and Žvaliauskas, Giedrius (2020) Populist Communication on Social Media. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Castellà, Josep Maria and Simonelli, Marco Antonio (2020) On the Institutional Context of Populism. Working Paper. -. Kubát, Michal and Mejstřík, Martin and Baloge, Martin and Bobba, Giuliano and Castillero, Daniel and Cremonesi, Cristina and Dobos, Gábor and Magre Ferran, Jaume and Hubé, Nicolas and Hüning, Hendrik and Ianosev, Bogdan and Klinge, Sune and Korkut, Umut and Krunke, Helle and Lembcke, Oliver and Lipinski, Artur and Mancosu, Moreno and Matic, Dejan and Medir, Lluis and Morkevičius, Vaidas and Pano, Esther and Roncarolo, Franca and Sahin, Osman and Seddone, Antonella and Školkay, Andrej and Sotiropoulos, Dimitri A. and Tsatsanis, Emmanouil and Wineroither, David M. and Žúborová, Viera and Žvaliauskas, Giedrius (2020) Populist Parties in Contemporary Europe. Working Paper. -. Korkut, Umut (2020) Hungary Coronavirus Emergency Legislation 2020. Public Jurist. Morkevičius, Vaidas and Raleckas, Rimantas and Žvaliauskas, Giedrius and Butkevičienė, Eglė and Boda, Zsolt and Bene, Márton (2020) Measuring Democratic Efficacy. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Bartha, Attila and Boda, Zsolt and Szikra, Dorottya (2020) When Populist Leaders Govern: Conceptualising Populism in Policy Making. Politics and Governance, 8 (3). ISSN 2183–2463 Bene, Márton Does context matter? A cross-country investigation of the effects of the media context on external and internal political efficacy (accepted manuscript at International Journal of Comparative Sociology). Bartha, Attila and Bazoti, Pery and Benedek, István and Butkevičien, Eglė and Katsikas, Dimitrios and Morkevičius, Vaidas and Sahin, Osman and Schlett, Bálint and Žvaliauskas, Giedrius (2020) What Kind of Public Policies Trigger Populism. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Ianosev, Bogdan and Sahin, Osman (2020) Can human evolution help us understand the support for populist movements? Political Insight, 11 (3). pp. 26-29. ISSN 2041-9066 Ozge, Ozduzen and Umut, Korhut and Cansu, Ozduzen (2020) ‘Refugees are not welcome’: Digital racism, online placemaking and the evolving categorization of Syrians in Turkey. New Media & Society, 22 (6). ISSN 1461-7315 Andreu, Josep Maria Castellà and Simonelli, Marco Antonio and Bencze, Mátyás and Gárdos Orosz, Fruzsina and Szente, Zoltán and Krunke, Helle and Klinge, Sune (2020) Populist constitutionalism. Its impact on the constitution, the judiciary and the role of the EU. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Körtvélyesi, Zsolt and Majtényi, Balázs (2020) Justifying supranational responses to the anti-constitutionalist challenge: Applying liberal multiculturalism as a background theory. Global Constitutionalism. pp. 1-24. ISSN 2045-3825 Krunke, Helle and Hovden, Katarina (2020) Transnational Solidarity Among European Cities. In: Transnational Solidarity. Cambridge University Press, pp. 393-417. Adina, Marincea and Andrej, Školkay (2020) Boris Kollár and OĽaNO Party Communication on Facebook. Politické Vedy (online), 23 (4). pp. 109-136. ISSN 1335 – 2741 Sahin, Osman (2021) How populists securitize elections to win them: the 2015 double elections in Turkey. New Perspectives on Turkey. pp. 1-24. ISSN 1305-3299 Boda, Zsolt (2021) Polarization and the disintegration of the polity. Reflections on populism and the future of liberal democracies. In: The future of liberal democracies: The rise of populism, 4 February 2021, Online webinar organised by the Hungarian Europe Society. (Unpublished) Bencze, Mátyás (2020) Explaining Judicial Populism in Hungary – a Legal Realist Approach. Iuris Dictio. pp. 83-96. ISSN 2528-7834 Hüning, Hendrik and Mechtenberg, Lydia and Wang, Stephanie W. (2021) Detecting argumentative discourse in online chat experiments. Working Paper. -. Bobba, Giuliano and Hubé, Nicolas (2021) COVID-19 and Populism: A Sui Generis Crisis. In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Sahin, Osman and Ianosev, Bogdan (2021) UK: Between managed moderation and far-right conspiracy theories. In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Magre, Jaume and Medir, Lluis and Pano, Esther (2021) Spain: Is ideology back in populist discourse? In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Bertero, Arturo and Seddone, Antonella (2021) Italy: Populist in the mirror, (de)politicizing the COVID-19 from government and opposition. In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Baloge, Martin and Hubé, Nicolas (2021) France: Governmental unpreparedness as a discursive opportunity for populists. In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Lembcke, Oliver W. (2021) Germany: The AfD’s Staggering between Reason and Resistance. In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Bene, Márton and Boda, Zsolt (2021) Hungary: Crisis as usual - Populist governance and the pandemic. In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Císař, Ondřej and Kubát, Michal (2021) Czech Republic: Running the State like a Family Business. In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Lipiński, Artur (2021) Poland: ‘If we don't elect the President, the country will plunge into chaos’. In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Bobba, Giuliano and Hubé, Nicolas (2021) Between mitigation and dramatization: The effect of the COVID-19 crisis on populists’ discourses and strategies. In: Populism and the Politicization of the COVID-19 Crisis in Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, https://www.palgrave.com/gp/book/9783030660109. ISBN 978-3-030-66011-6, DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-66011-6 Mechtenberg, Lydia and Perino, Grischa and Treich, Nicolas and Tyran, Jean-Robert and Wang, Stephanie W. (2021) Self-Signaling in Moral Voting. Working Paper. -, Discussion Paper Series, CEPR Centre for Economic Policy Research, London, UK. Lipiński, Artur (2020) Populism and media opportunity structures. The case of new media. Władza sądzenia (Power of judgement). ISSN 2300-1690 Cabot, Pere-Lluís Huguet and Dankers, Verna and Abadi, David and Fischer, Agneta and Shutova, Ekaterina (2020) The Pragmatics behind Politics: Modelling Metaphor, Framing and Emotion in Political Discourse. ACL Anthology. Huguet-Cabot, Pere-Lluís and Abadi, David and Fischer, Agneta and Shutova, Ekaterina (2021) Us vs. Them: A Dataset of Populist Attitudes, News Bias and Emotions. In: Proceedings of the 16th Conference of the European Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Main Volume, Anthology ID:2021.eacl-main.165. Association for Computational Linguistics, EACL, pp. 1921-1945. Fischer, Agneta and Brands, Charlotte and Abadi, David (2020) The Expression of Right-Wing Populism in the Netherlands across Facebook Posts. Other. -, OSFPreprints. Lironi, Elisa and Nahr, Hendrik and Nugent, Rhys (2021) Civic Strategies Addressing Populism - Initiatives to safeguard liberal democracies. Working Paper. -. Klinge, Sune and Krunke, Helle and Fallentin Nyborg, Annemette and Rytter, Jens Elo (2020) Covid-19 and Constitutional Law in Denmark. In: Covid-19 and Constitutional Law. Covid-19 et droit constitutionnel. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas, Biblioteca Jurídica Virtual. ISBN 978-607-30-4290-1 Bene, Márton and Boda, Zsolt (2021) Democratic Efficacy and Populist Attitudes: A Conceptual and Empirical Exploration. In: Current Populism in Europe: Gender-Backlash and Counter-strategies. HBS Prague, pp. 65-78. ISBN 978-80-88289-26-5 Bertero, Arturo (2021) The COVID-19 Related Communication of Italian Politicians and Its Success on Facebook. In: Current Populism in Europe: Gender-Backlash and Counter-strategies. HBS Prague, pp. 79-94. ISBN 978-80-88289-26-5 Školkay, Andrej (2021) The Cause and Retort of Populism: A Formal Political Reasoning (Politics) Without Distinct Ideology as a Response to a Political-Moral Crisis – Turning Laclau’s Theory into a Research Tool. In: Current Populism in Europe: Gender-Backlash and Counter-strategies. HBS Prague, pp. 95-113. ISBN 978-80-88289-26-5 Darminova, Nasiya (2021) Rule of law vs. Poland and Hungary – An inconsistent approach? Hungarian Journal of Legal Studies, 60 (3). pp. 236-259. ISSN 2560-1067 Gárdos Orosz, Fruzsina (2021) The reference to constitutional traditions in populist constitutionalism – The case of Hungary. Hungarian Journal of Legal Studies. ISSN 2560-1067 Mihajlović, Borko and Turanjanin, Veljko (2020) When populists govern: The case of economic and criminal justice policy in Bosnia and Hercegovina. Archive for Legal and Social Sciences, 2 (1). pp. 5-24. Krešić, Boris (2020) Populism and pronatality policy with reference to BIH. Archive for Legal and Social Sciences, 2 (1). pp. 25-37. Gárdos Orosz, Fruzsina and Szente, Zoltán, eds. (2021) Populist Challenges to Constitutional Interpretation in Europe and Beyond (1st ed.). Routledge. ISBN 9781003148944 Bartha, Attila and Kopasz, Marianna and Takács, Judit (2020) Are the Populists Doing Better? Public Policy Lessons of the Coronavirus Pandemic: Management of the Pandemic in Europe's Liberal and Populist Democracies. In: Vírusba oltott politika: Világjárvány és politikatudomány (Virus Vaccinated by Politics: Pandemics and Political Sciences vaccinated). Napvilág Kiadó, Budapest, pp. 89-108. ISBN 978-963-338-465-7 Fallentin Nyborg, Annemette and Klinge, Sune and Krunke, Helle and Rytter, Jens Elo (2020) Covid-19 and emergency Laws in Denmark. Svensk Juristtidning (10). p. 1098. Sotiropoulos, Dimitri A. (2021) Populism, Party Politics and the Economic Crisis in Greece: a Comparison with the case of Portugal. In: Greece and the Euro: from crisis to recovery. Hellenic Observatory, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK., https://www.lse.ac.uk/Hellenic-Observatory/Publications/Staff-Books-and-Publications, pp. 252-282. Abadi, David and Arnaldo, Irene and Fischer, Agneta (2020) Anxious and Angry: Emotional and Political Motives for Approving of and Complying with Hygiene Measures related to the COVID-19 Pandemic. Working Paper. -, PsyArXiv Preprints. Abadi, David and Cabot, Pere-Lluís Huguet and Duyvendak, Jan Willem and Fischer, Agneta (2020) Socio-Economic or Emotional Predictors of Populist Attitudes across Europe. Working Paper. -, PsyArXiv Preprints. Horváthy, Balázs and Szép, Viktor (2021) Populist policy positions in the European Parliament - The Eurozone Crisis. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Karamanidou, Lena (2021) Populist Parties: Migration Policy and Discourses in the European Parliament. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Gruszczynski, Lukasz and Friedery, Réka and Crescenzi, Andrea and Dimitriadi, Angeliki and du Vall, Katarzyna and Forastiero, Rosita and Körtvélyesi, Zsolt and Školkay, Andrej and Szép, Viktor (2021) The Populist Challenge of Common EU Policies - The Case of (Im)migration. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Abadi, David and Arnaldo, Irene and Fischer, Agneta (2021) Anxious and Angry: Emotional Responses to the COVID-19 Threat. Frontiers in Psychology, 12 (676116). Sahin, Osman and Vegetti, Federico and Korkut, Umut and Bobba, Giuliano and Mancosu, Moreno and Seddone, Antonella and Stępińska, Agnieszka and Bennett, Samuel and Lipiński, Artur and Sotiropoulos, Dimitri A. and Tsatsanis, Manos and Mitsikostas, Alexia and Árendás, Zsuzsanna and Messing, Vera and Hubé, Nicolas and Baloge, Martin (2021) Citizens’ Reactions to Populism in Europe: How do target groups respond to the populist challenge? Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Marincea, Adina and Školkay, Andrej and Baloge, Martin and Bertero, Arturo and Bobba, Giuliano and Hubé, Nicolas and Lipiński, Artur and Mancosu, Moreno and Matic, Dejan and Sahin, Osman and Tsatsanis, Emmanouil and Sotiropoulos, Dimitri A. (2021) Populism and Social Media: A comparative analysis of populists’ shared content and networks on Facebook. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Lembcke, Oliver W. (2021) Mapping Policy Patterns of Populist Parties. A Quantitative Cross-Country Analysis. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Mejstřík, Martin and Kubát, Michal and Baloge, Martin and Dobos, Gábor and Hubé, Nicolas and Hüning, Hendrik and Lipiński, Artur and Magre, Jaume and Medir, Lluís and Pano, Esther and Školkay, Andrej (2021) Impacts of Populism on the Party Systems. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Pano, Esther and Medir, Lluís and Magre, Jaume and Havlik, Vlastimil and Dobos, Gábor and Belluati, Marinella and Bobba, Giuliano and Roncarolo, Franca and Seddone, Antonella and Sahin, Osman (2021) Populist Governance in Regional and Local Governments. Working Paper. -. (Unpublished) Boda, Zsolt (2021) The effect of political regimes on policy agendas: A theoretical framework. In: Policy Agendas in Autocracy, and Hybrid Regimes - The Case of Hungary. Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 19-32. ISBN 978-3-030-73222-6 Gárdos Orosz, Fruzsina (2021) Two Influential Concepts: Socialist Legality and Constitutional Identity and Their Impact on the Independence of the Judiciary. German Law Journal, 22 (SI 7). 1327 -1343. Bartha, Attila and Sotiropoulos, Dimitri A. and Katsikas, Dimitris and Pap, András László and Tóth, Mihály and Halász, Bálint and Žvaliauskas, Giedrius and Morkevičius, Vaidas and Butkevičienė, Eglė and Lipiński, Artur and Školkay, Andrej and Daniš, Igor and Vass-Vígh, Veronika and Krešić, Boris and Turanjanin, Veljko and Mihajlović, Borko and Sahin, Osman (2021) Populist Governance and Policies in Europe. Working Paper. -. Sotiropoulos, Dimitri A. (2022) Who are the populists and how to respond to them: Evidence from mainstream European Parliament parties.
URI:	https://openarchive.tk.mta.hu/id/eprint/514

Actions (login required)

View Item